Production Report – Observational Documentary

Observational Documentaries aim to provide a scene that allows for the character, or main prop, to be in focus. They leave the setting untouched, with little movement, as a way to highlight a character in their natural, candid state. The audience are spectators in a character’s life rather than the character being aware of a camera, the characters are uninterrupted by action and full focus can be on them and their actions. Often this indicates an important scene, or an emotional moment where the audience realises something that would not be shown through close camera use and constant movement. Furthermore, observational mode often demonstrates vulnerability, and openness, the camera captures every movement of what is in scene and allows for an audiences eyes to wander and relate setting to character.

Film makers may often use this form of filming in order to demonstrate a new perspective, that of human experience. In order to gain a firm grasp on a characters actions and feelings, the observational mode introduces a setting for movement to seem small, yet important. Human thought and feeling is portrayed slowly; each move makes a large impact on a steady screen, when there is a lack of movement, the minuscule details from a character is exposed. A film maker will do this to emphasise how the character is feeling in the moment, what thought process they are going through, and the importance of their actions. Cinéma Vérité translates into “truthful cinema”, this proposes the idea of audience, and film maker, to have no interference within the scene, we are stood out the way and watch the character, while real life events unfold.

CI: To create an observational documentary that includes mise-en-scene, movement and framing to communicate a certain feeling, sense, or setting.

Shots and how they used framing and composition to add meaning to the sense of the school / Sixth Form Centre as a place.

Shot 1Shot 2Shot 3

Shot 1, left: I find this shot one of my favourites. The focus on a foreground object rather than the characters in the background creates a serene atmosphere, by using a shallow depth of field allows for us to take our focus away from the characters and enjoy the setting around it. The shallow depth of field also helps to negate distractions and focus on the main object, while here it is simply a rock it still creates a sense of calmness, and intrigues us into what the two characters are talking about, and why we can’t get closer to see. Keeping the characters far from the camera inspires that curiosity and allows us to sit back and question the meaning for this camera position and focus. The Sixth Form is presented as a private area, not cramped and busy, instead open and relaxing – where there is little interruption from others or nature.

 

Shot 2, middle: This shot is good in my opinion as the wide angle, along with the centered position of the character creates a strange atmosphere, the eerily empty corridor along with the symmetrical lining of lockers is utilised to further emphasise isolation, simplicity and curiosity. The shot from the backs makes the audience feel as though they are invisible spectators to the character’s life. We serve as cameras watching the character go on in their life, without them noticing. This means the character is in their raw, natural state as they walk away, we get an insight on their feelings and therefore actions. Without being able to see the face, we are left to interpret how they might be feeling, further adding to the audience and their interest. As they walk through the corridor, we see the sixth form as a route to get somewhere important, they walk through with meaning and confidence, directly down the middle before they turn a corner. This could indicate emptiness of the school, or rather an abnormality in the day-to-day life that normally goes on during school.

Shot 3, right: Similarly to shot 2, I like this shot due to the symmetrically of the room, and its objects. The shot has no movement other than a light flickering of the lamp. This is commonly used in horrors or serious moments within film. Used here, I feel as though it highlights isolation and creates a desolate, lonely environment. The spacious room, contrasted by the lack of movement further connotes the eerie atmosphere and causes us to question where everyone is, and why there is nobody here. Additionally, the positioning of the camera above the room, as well a centered indicates importance and vulnerability from below. Here we have the superior stance at the top, yet there is nothing below, the makes you camera feels alone and forgotten, rather than intimidating as most high angles would do.

In the future I would like to incorporate a wider range of movement, or involvement of a character/s. I feel like meaning is created greatly through not only the setting, but what happens within the setting, and a character’s actions. This would help enhance the audience’s view Sixth form, and what is we wish to present through the camera.

Genre & Narrative in The Shawshank Redemption.

Genre – Generic prison attributes in The Shawshank Redemption

  • Events / Scenes
    • Main Character is sent to prison and has to adjust to prison life. Along the way Andy builds up friendships with Red, Guards and the Warden. He also finds enemies such as Bogs, and goes through many disturbing actions present in a prison. Andy deals with violence and but also epiphany, as his intelligence leads to success. He escapes at the end by tunneling and tricks the Warden, leads to Warden being imprisoned.
  • Characters
    • Protagonist, Andy Dufresne as ‘new fish’ or Red, as narrator. Red is the guy who knows everything about prison, lifetimer. Andy, brand new and not experienced in prison. Wrongly accused and thinks he shouldn’t be here. Red’s friends like Andy, all become friends. Antagonist Warden, Guards and Bogs (the Sisters), don’t like Andy until Andy does something for them or to them. Oppressive and selfish versus Andy who does things in order to please people that he sees interest in.
  • Setting
    • Prison settings, tall stone walls. Barren and desolate, feeling of isolation. Total indication of being imprisoned, it’s an inescapable area.
  • Mise-en-scene (Iconography)
    • Classic worn, broken items. Disgusting prison gruel, very little hygiene or sanitation. Iron bars, metal and stone. Basic prison outfits, grubby clothing and shoes. Guards and Warden wearing suits, in comparison to prisoners who get very little. Pale and bruised prisoners, constant beating. Labour-harsh jobs, laundry, cleaning, washing etc = isolation and encasement. End of movie, flowers, nature = freedom.
  • Production Technique (Specifically mise-en-scene & camera)
    • Dark gloomy lighting, high shots to show small vs greatness. Isolation within a prison full of people. Dissimilarities between people, dehumanises them. Variety of angles, wide at end to highlight how prisoners (Red and Andy) have gained freedom. Close ups to indicate intrusiveness and intensity, such as violent scenes.

Do you think the film subverts or challenges the genre?

I believe the film subverts the genre, it follows generic themes of a main character entering a prison, a place which is new to them, and gaining knowledge and friends along the way. It follows the classic escape and the built up to it. Small hints that collect at the end to became that ‘great escape’. Andy gains popularity and importance in prison, uses something (his knowledge) to climb up the prison hierarchy, defeats antagonists such as the Sisters and the Warden. Receives freedom and redemption after escaping.

Narrative – Use of narration in The Shawshank Redemption

  • The tone, mood and poetry of the voice.
    • Red, very monotone voice, but sense of sympathy when talking about Andy. He talks highly of Andy and pities him when he is harmed. Is sure not to get emotional, very amiable and casual when talking. He’s seen many people come through, yet Andy catches his eye, he concentrates on Andy and looks out for him through narration, highlighting the things he does good and cleverly manipulates his experience within prison differently to how anyone else has done.
  • The relationship between the restricted narrative and the omniscient narrator
    • Omniscient narrator looks at the themes within a film with wisdom and insight. It answers the central question of the film and reveals the point of the film.
  • The fact that the narrator is a central character in the film
    • This allows for a closer relationship between audience and narrator, the narrator is able to position himself in the movie and create further relation between characters. Having a narrator frequently involved in scenes means the audience gains first hand experience and an opinion from the narrator. It also sometimes creates a bias, by interacting most with the narrator, and listening to their point of view, we gain their understanding of scenes rather than seeing it from all the characters.
  • The themes which are revealed in the denouement (act 3)
    • Escape
    • Corruption
    • Freedom

Pan’s Labyrinth Final Essay

‘The Pale Man’s lair. How does mise-en-scene communicate meaning for the audience and reinforce the themes & messages that Guillermo Del Toro is trying to communicate in Pan’s Labyrinth?’

Pan’s Labyrinth is a fantasy-horror guided film, it follows the journey of a young girl called Ofelia who is midst growing up and maturing in the aftermath of the Spanish civil war, where fascism controlled the country. Del Toro infuses a series of magical, surreal aspects into the real, violent political issues that are happening around Ofelia and her family. The film follows Ofelia as she swaps from both realities, her mythical land and the coup that aims to kill off remaining rebels. Ofelia and the characters around her explore themes of conflict and disobedience, Del Toro controversially demonstrates how the typical idea of disobedience as a negative action, gains rewards in his mindset. In his film, those who oppose tyranny are rewarded and those who dish out corruption are condemned. He does this to present his ideas on fascism and corrupt power and how far he disagrees with it.

The initial setting of the scene as Ofelia makes her way through the wall resembles that of a Church, long pillars with small windows where light shines through, archways that leer over Ofelia as she walks through. Churches are very similar, little light other than the rays that come through windows and talls roofs. These old-fashioned archways leading down to where the pale man is sat almost indicates that he should be worshipped. The stone hallway, with cracks and aged decoration leading up to seeing him, emphasises the idea that this room is similar to that of a temple. Paintings of the pale man devouring children implies a form of worship and thus effort was taken to present the pale man to others, as a piece of artwork. Just as Churches are designated as a place of worship and adoration of Christ, this scene is a demonstration of worship for the pale man. The church at this time in Spain was a very wealthy organisation yet under fascist regimes, caused a lot of violence. The violent aspects, such as those paintings, resemble the church and the literal “blood on their hands”. The Pale Man has an entire table of food in front of him yet he feasts on innocent children, such as the government feasts on the innocent civilians and manipulates them through the fascist laws and ideologies.

Another demonstration of Mise-en-Scene is the notable gruesome costume of the pale man. The wrinkly, pale man sat at the end of the table contrasts the traditional beauty of christian churches, and furthermore the glamorous structure of the setting. Archways with stone flooring would normally lead to a beautiful center room, but here the audience is met with a horrifying sight, a pale figure. The fact the pale man is sat at the head of the table mirrors the scene of Vidal’s feast. In some way, it could be argued that the pale man represents Captain Vidal and his capitalist ideologies. The horrific monster that Ofelia sees in this scene could demonstrate how Ofelia views Vidal, the frightening costume consisting of saggy skin and little facial features, used by the pale man hints towards Ofelia’s coping mechanism, even in her fantasy escape, she sees Vidal, but in a different aspect. She struggles to find refuge from her step-father, such as the struggle for rebels to hide from the fascist military. Wherever she goes, and the rebels go, Vidal follows and attempts to kill. This reflects Del Toro’s mindset towards fascist Spain and his dislike towards their ideologies, he reinforces the idea that there is little freedom under this control and you have nowhere to hide from the government’s rules and legislation.

Del Toro incorporates his views on society at the time through certain aspects. One evident point is that of capitalism. Vidal and the pale man both sit at the head of the table; it could be argued that the masses of food and drink laying on the table in this scene represents the resources capitalist leaders and wealthy citizens who benefit from Spain’s fascist ideologies, that they are unwilling to share; even if they own much more than they need. Del Toro highlights the nationalists’ greed through the pale man. A colour palette of warm reds and oranges surrounds the table and leads Ofelia into a false sense of security, while the abundance of food should connote nourishment and comfort, here it tempts her to her death. The reds and oranges in reality here foreshadow death and represent violence. Del Toro includes another religious lexis into his work; the temptation of sin. Ofelia is tempted into taking grapes, and disobeys the order of the fawn; she resembles Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden.

 

CC – some great evidence of understanding of the historical context and of the director context. You just need some quotes in this and evidence of your research as this is required to get top marks in this section

FE – you have some great moments here but some are a little unfocused. Try to pick ONE example and make sure you have the analysis / connotations at each stage before jumping to the links to context / genre / narrative.

RWWF – this is excellent – you do a great job of consistently linking back to the narrative and the context of the whole film. You could just do with considering genre perhaps a touch more throughout.

 

Targets: For next time, my aims are going to focus on making solid points, and concentrating on one example and fully analysing that with a good, clear explanation and further connotations rather than running off and starting another point, leaving the previous example unfinished.  I should also demonstrate a better use of cultural context, where I use quotes as well as research evidence within the essay. To do this I will find articles on directors, setting and background information on the movie and include that through quotes in the essay.